I wasn’t going to see Rent this time around. It’s my comfort musical, and I love it, but I always wonder just how many times I need to go. However, those canny folks at Opera Australia suckered me in with a free dinner promotion. Second row dress circle tickets and a delicious grilled barramundi dinner with a beer for $99?! It’d be rude not to! So I found myself at my fifth production of Rent last night.
I’m not one of those people who see a show multiple times within the same run. It’s always a show here and there. I saw the original Australian run in Naarm/Melbourne in 1998, a production in Philadelphia while I was holidaying there in 2004, an amateur theatre production in Mulubinba/Newcastle in 2017, and another production in Darkinjung Country/Wyong as the world was emerging from lockdowns in 2021. When you add in my familiarity with the original Broadway cast through the soundtrack and film, I know this musical better than any other. I have such clear ideas about what it’s “supposed” to be and opinions about what new productions get right, and what they get wrong. So how does the latest iteration playing at the Opera House measure up? On the whole, remarkably well.
There were some standout performances. I remarked last time I saw Rent that Sean Miley Moore’s Angel was the best I’d ever seen. Sorry Sean, but I think Jesse Dutlow may have stolen your crown. They floored me with their incredible vocals and heart. When a production casts Angel right, they’re halfway there. Calista Nelmes’ Maureen was breathtaking with vocals that hit that high bar Idina Menzel set and true commitment to this challenging role. She was matched beautifully by Imani Williams as Joanne. This is one of the more understated roles in the musical, one that can easily get overlooked because the character is straightlaced and doesn’t have any solo songs. However, Imani is so magnetic with such powerful pipes and personality that my eyes were drawn to her whenever she was on stage. And when she came together with Calista on “Take Me Or Leave Me,” my favourite song in Rent, I was spellbound.
This production didn’t take as many risks as the one I saw in 2021, preferring instead to stay faithful to Jonathan Larson’s original vision. While Jonathan created a brilliant music, I would always love to see productions putting their stamp on the show. There were a few little moments where this production changed things up, with mixed results. I can’t remember another production where Angel cried out in anguish as they lay in the hospital bed during “Without You.” I felt myself starting to tear up at that, much earlier than I normally do. Watching Angel ascend and get their wings in “Contact” was visually so powerful. However, I feel like introducing marijuana into “Santa Fe” diminished this song’s honest yearning for a different, better life, turning it into nothing but stoner ramblings. It deserved better. I’m also not sure the cardboard cutout policemen were nearly as effective as real humans might have been. They took me out of every scene they appeared.
Ultimately, Rent is about community, so it was only fitting that I felt this show was at its best when the cast came together. Special songs like “Seasons of Love” and “La Vie Boheme” were highlights. Hearing the voices of the stellar principles and chorus, watching their faces as they bounced off one another, was beautiful. And Rent is beautiful. There’s a reason I keep coming back to it. Whether you’re a longtime fan like me or you’ve never seen it, there are plenty of reasons to check out Opera Australia’s new version. It plays at the Opera House until November 1. Tickets are available now from the Opera Australia website.
Image source: Opera Australia media centre